UTS Journalism: News and Current Affairs - summer course

Links & Resources

Judith Miller's Website...The bio from her own website.

Wikipedia's Miller Bio...Judith Miller (born January 2, 1948 in New York City) was a writer for The New York Times. She announced her retirement from The New York Times on November 9, 2005. Miller, based in Washington D.C., was a prominent journalist who had access to top U.S. government officials.

Judith Miller's WMD Problem...Returning home to Las Vegas, the star New York Times reporter who saw WMD in Iraq romanticizes nuclear childhood and omits conflict of interest.Greg Mitchell, Editor & Publisher. Posted April 4, 2005.

Judith Miller Named Editor-In-Chief Of TV Guide...Ex-New York Times reporter praised for ability to uncritically promote sources’ agendas... She’ll be responsible for guiding its coverage of popular TV shows and the celebrities who star in them. “This is a job that requires a journalist who’s able to make sources trust her completely so she can promote their work without any other views or complicating facts getting in the way,” said Rich Batista, CEO of parent company Gemstar-TV Guide. “Judith’s experience is the perfect fit.”

Rethinking Miller: Was She So Bad?....Sometimes the smoke of battle has to clear before vital issues can be seen. So it is with the Judith Miller affair. Despite all the official niceties that accompanied Ms. Miller’s recent departure from The New York Times, few people doubt that she was pushed into retirement.

Who is Judy Miller Kidding?...Intentionally or not, Judith Miller worked hand in glove helping the White House propaganda machine sell the war in Iraq.

Discussing the 'martyrdom' of Judith Miller...I think she is totally misguided, but I also think that the media is pretty fickle, and we saw a few months ago, she was the martyr of the day, the saint of the day. And now she's the villain of the day. It's kind of hard to explain that, except by thinking that it's got something to do with the media feeling anxious about its own role.

Final words:
Summing up Judy Miller
...The Judith Miller debacle has fascinated newspaper people for months, and it has been a fascinating story in its own right. The New York Times reporter saw her reputation as a journalist yoyo over the months. First savaged for her unquestioning reporting on weapons of mass destruction, she became a martyr when she went to jail for nearly three months rather than reveal her source in the Valerie Plame CIA leak case. Then the savaging resumed, much of it now open and coming from Times colleagues, culminating in a scathing memo from Times executive editor Bill Keller saying the paper erred by standing behind Miller as it did.

Judith Iscariot, Miller sells journalism down the river. Again...To put it as plainly as possible, Miller didn't want to testify about the Vice President's right hand man not because he forbade her to—on the contrary, he gave her his authorization from the get-go—but rather because she had good reason to believe Libby wanted her to lie. And in Judith Miller's bizarre, journalistically compromised world, it is less important to catch a powerful official in a blatant lie than it is to protect your friendly relationship with a productive, high-ranking source.

 

 

Judith Miller: Biography

Judith Miller worked for 28 years as a senior reporter and investigative journalist for the New York Times. She produced award-winning work and shared the 2002 Pulitzer Prize for Explanatory Reporting . But she became a figure of controversy following her articles about weapons of mass destruction in the lead up to the Iraq war.

In July 2005 she was held in contempt of court and spent 85 days in prison for refusing to disclose the source of a leak relating to the identity of an undercover CIA agent, Valerie Plame.

This case has sparked much debate relating to shield laws for journalists, as well as dividing opinion about Miller. Since her release from prison, and subsequent resignation from her post at The New York Times, Miller states that she has focused on seeking protection for journalists and their sources through campaigning for a Federal shield law .

Her work has included books and journalistic pieces on war and terrorism, al Qaeda, biowarfare and general on the Middle East. She has most notably been criticised for her articles on Iraq's weapons of mass destruction which a number of commentators have argued helped build a case fo the American led war in Iraq.

Education and career

Judith Miller grew up in Los Angeles with a Jewish father and Irish Catholic mother. She graduated from Barnard College in 1969 and then went on to do her Masters at Princeton University's Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs. While researching a paper for her Masters, Miller travelled to Jerusalem where she formed an interest in the Israeli-Palestinian dispute that was to influence her career.

She began working for The New York Times at the Washington bureau in 1977 after working as a correspondent for The Progressive and National Public Radio. Her new role at the paper saw her covering stories on the Arab world, foreign affairs and the Middle East.

In 1983 she was appointed The Times' Cairo bureau chief. She returned to Washington in 1987-88 and continued her work, becoming a Times’ special correspondent covering the Persian Gulf crisis in 1990.

This reaffirmed Miller’s legitimacy as an authority on military matters, nuclear weaponry and bio warfare which led to her becoming a bestselling author with various books such as Germs: Biological Weapons and America’s Secret War. Such publishing ventures in turn consolidated her earlier interest in this area of reportage.

In 1993, she married author and founder of Anchor Books, Jason Epstein.

Miller and Iraq

In the lead up to the 2003 war in Iraq, Miller wrote a number of key New York Times stories that purported to provide evidence, from both ananymous and nammed sources, that Sadam Hussein had stockpiles of various chemical and biological weapons of mass destruction. These are now known to be based on flase and or misleading evidence. But as Slate media critic Jack Schaffer writes, although Miller became a virtual evangelist for the WMD story she did so with a sense of journalistic self protection:

To be sure, Miller never asserted that Iraq had an illegal WMD program or a stockpile of banned weapons. Far from it: Every time she writes about WMDs, she always constructs a semantic trapdoor allowing her to pop out the other side and proclaim, It's the sources talking, not me! But thanks to the reporting of the Washington Post's Howard Kurtz, we now know Miller was a true believer who grew fat on WMD tips from her sources inside Ahmad Chalabi's Iraqi National Congress organization, and that once in-country she threw a bit and saddle on the WMD detectives and rode them like Julie Krone from one end of Iraq to the other to investigate those tips.

While reporting as an embedded journalist in Iraq in 2003, Miller actively harranged US military forces and Iraqi officials to follow up leads from her sources in the search for weapons of mass destruction. When no weapons were found Miller later claimed this failure was a result of a disorganised US military.

Key Career Dates

Early 1970s – Judith Miller completed university and became Washington bureau chief of a monthly publication called The Progressive and contributed to National Public Radio.

1977 - Joined The New York Times Washington Bureau, where she covered the securities industry, Congress, politics, and foreign affairs, particularly Middle Eastern affairs.

1983 - Appointed The Times’ Cairo bureau chief to report on the Arab world.

1986 - Became The Times’ Paris correspondent.  

1987 – Became the Washington bureau's news editor and deputy bureau chief.

1990 – Miller’s first book titled, One, By One, By One was published. It is an account of how people in six nations have distorted the memory of the Holocaust. During the same year, she co-authored the best-selling Saddam Hussein and the Crisis in the Gulf.

October 1990 – Named special correspondent to the Persian Gulf crisis, and after that, The Times' Sunday Magazine's special correspondent.

1996 – Wrote a book titled God Has Ninety-Nine Names, which explores the spread of Islamic extremism in ten Middle Eastern countries.

2001 – Co-authored the best-selling book, Germs: Biological Weapons and America’s Secret War.

2002 – Part of a small team that won a Pulitzer Prize for Explanatory Journalism for a January 2001 series on Osama bin Laden and Al Qaeda.

May 2004 – In an unprecedent move The Times publishes an apology for errors in its pre-Iraq war intelligence stories. Miller’s byline was on 4 of the 6 articles that The Times nammed as faulty

July - October 2005 – Miller spent 85 days in jail after refusing to reveal sources in the CIA leak case involving Valerie Plame. She went from an outcast, with whom some Times’ colleagues refused to share a byline, to an heroic icon. The Times went from apologising for her work to comparing her to Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King Jr in a series of editorials.

9 November 2005 – Resigned from Times, citing among other reasons, difficulties performing her job effectively after having become an integral part of the stories she was sent to cover. However, her retirement may not have been voluntary – her journalism had come under intense criticism with accusations that she had been made into a shill of the Bush administration.

14 November 2005 – Started new job as editor-in-chief of TV Guide and is responsible for guiding its coverage of popular television shows.

 

Sarah Crawford, Jessica Madden, Alice O’Keefe, Justin Stevens and Karen Tong from the 2006 NACAF Summer contributed to this page.

   This site was designed by Marcus O'Donnell for N&CA Summer 2005-2006